Fisher vs. Trapper Stardew Valley
by Collette Tilly in

Welcome to the world of Stardew Valley, where you can farm, mine, forage, and drumroll fish! Fishing can be one of the most relaxing yet rewarding ways to spend your time in this charming game, but do you know your Fisher from your Trapper? That’s what we’re here to explore today in this Fisher vs. Trapper Stardew Valley showdown.

What are Fishing Skills in Stardew Valley?

Before we dive into the Fisher vs. Trapper debate, let’s talk about fishing skills. In Stardew Valley, players can improve their abilities in various activities, including fishing. As you gain experience points (XP) in fishing, your skill level increases, bringing with it increased proficiency and some sweet rewards.

When you reach level 5, you get to choose between two professions: Fisher or Trapper. This decision can have a significant impact on your fishing gameplay and, ultimately, your farm’s success. So, which one should you choose? Let’s dive deeper into both professions and find out!

Fisher Profession: A Catch Worth Reeling In

The Fisher profession is all about making your fishing more profitable. When you choose the Fisher profession, the selling price of your fish will increase by 25%. This means more gold in your pocket when you sell your catch!

But wait, there’s more! When you reach fishing level 10, you can choose between the following perks:

See also  Caviar Connoisseurs, Unite! How to Get Caviar in Stardew Valley


As an Angler, the value of your fish increases by an additional 50%. That’s a 75% total increase in the selling price of your fish! If you’re looking to maximize your profits from fishing, the Angler path is a no-brainer.


If treasure hunting is more your style, then the Pirate profession might be for you. As a Pirate, you’ll have double the chance of finding treasure chests while fishing. This means more loot, artifacts, and rare items for your collection.

So, should you choose the Fisher profession? If you’re a dedicated fisherman looking to maximize profits or hunt for treasures, then the Fisher profession is an excellent choice. But let’s not make a hasty decision. Read on to find out what the Trapper profession has to offer!

Fisher vs. Trapper Stardew Valley 1

Trapper Profession: Lay Your Trap and Reap the Rewards

The Trapper profession is all about making your crab pots more efficient. When you choose the Trapper profession, the resources required to craft crab pots are significantly reduced. Instead of needing 40 wood and 3 iron bars, you’ll only need 25 wood and 2 copper bars. That’s a big saving!

Like the Fisher profession, when you reach level 10, you have two additional perks to choose from:


If you opt for the Mariner profession, the crab pots you place will no longer produce trash items. This means every catch will be a valuable one, making it easier to turn a profit or fill up your Community Center bundles.


As a Luremaster, your crab pots will no longer require bait. This can save you a significant amount of time and resources, especially if you’re managing multiple crab pots.

See also  How to Get Burglar Ring Stardew: Unleashing Your Inner Thief in Stardew Valley

So, should you choose the Trapper profession? If you’re a fan of passive income and want to make the most of your crab pots, the Trapper profession is the way to go. But is it better than the Fisher profession? Let’s find out!

Fisher vs. Trapper Stardew Valley: The Verdict

Now that we’ve explored both professions, it’s time to decide which one is the winner in the Fisher vs. Trapper Stardew Valley showdown.

If you’re an active fisherman who enjoys casting your line and reeling in a big catch, the Fisher profession is the clear winner. With increased profits and the chance for treasure hunting, you’ll be raking in the gold in no time. Plus, the Angler profession offers the highest profit boost when it comes to selling fish, making it an attractive choice for those looking to maximize their income from fishing.

On the other hand, if you prefer a more laid-back approach to fishing and want to focus on your crab pots, then the Trapper profession is the way to go. With reduced crafting costs, no bait requirements (if you choose Luremaster), and no more trash items in your pots (if you choose Mariner), you’ll be able to generate a steady stream of passive income with minimal effort.

Ultimately, the decision between Fisher and Trapper in Stardew Valley comes down to your personal playstyle and priorities. If you’re passionate about fishing and want to maximize your profits, go for the Fisher profession. If you prefer passive income and want to optimize your crab pots, then the Trapper profession is the better choice.

See also  Guide to Finding Leeks in Stardew Valley: It's No Leek in the Park!

Wrapping Up the Fisher vs. Trapper Showdown

Stardew Valley offers players a variety of activities to engage in, and fishing is undoubtedly one of the most relaxing and rewarding. Whether you choose the Fisher or Trapper profession, you’re sure to enjoy the many benefits that come with leveling up your fishing skills.

Now that you’ve got the lowdown on the Fisher vs. Trapper Stardew Valley debate, it’s time to grab your fishing rod or craft some crab pots and start reaping the rewards! Whatever path you choose, happy fishing, and may the biggest catch be yours!

Collette Tilly is an avid gamer and writer with a particular passion for WoW, Diablo and The Sims 4. Collette is also a proud owner of a black cat, who secretly wants to take over the world. When she's not gaming or writing, Collette enjoys indulging in her guilty pleasure of watching 'trash' TV series.
Share Post:

Related Posts